This award goes to the most rocking, interesting and entertaining music or puzzle game, regardless of Nintendo platform.

Unanimous Winner: Elite Beat Agents

Steven Rodriguez: The original Japanese game won our award for Best Import of 2005, and it looks like Beat Agents is going to live up to that. Even with just two songs in the E3 demo, it's hilarious and awesome, just like the original. (Girl = Field Goal!)

Jonathan Metts: Not many games at E3 can make me laugh out loud. Elite Beat Agents had me chuckling loudly the whole time. I'm a huge fan of Ouendan, and I couldn't be more excited about this English-language sequel.

Daniel Bloodworth: Many doubted that Ouendan could ever make the jump overseas with its odd scenarios and manga flair. However, the two songs demoed at E3 show that iNiS has succeeded in making a game that doesn’t feel too Japanese, yet retains the humor and randomness of the original.

Commander Khan: Agents Are...GO!