We store cookies, you can get more info from our privacy policy.
3DS

Nintendo Direct: Cautiously Optimistically Cautious

by Alex Culafi - February 15, 2013, 11:01 am EST
Total comments: 11

Hype and cynicism galore.

This was some Direct, huh? When the stream wasn't working quite right for me until the last minute, I guessed we were getting a 10-minute Reggie show with an Animal Crossing release date and the reveal of the inevitable surprise summer game. And when Iwata came on with his 2013 Club Nintendo Platinum hat calling this the "Year of Luigi," and following it with 10 minutes of Luigi's Mansion talk, I thought Iwata was just hyping up the 3DS sequel. As we now know, I was wrong. Wonderfully, wonderfully wrong.

After Luigi's Mansion, we were greeted with a Mario & Luigi game, a Mario golf game, and some New Super Mario Bros. U DLC. Let's go down the list.

Mario & Luigi: Dream Team

Thank goodness for the fact that we're finally getting a real Mario RPG after the Miyamoto-based trash that was Sticker Star. While AlphaDream is an incredibly talanted studio that has made great games, I am curious about how this title turns out. The new gimmick looks like as cool a twist as the one in Bowser's Inside Story—if they do it right. Ultimately, I'm hoping this game retains all the great RPG action and writing of the first three titles (even Partners in Time!) while naturally evolving the series to keep it fresh. In other words, I would like the changes to be a healthy balance between the stale New Super Mario Bros. 2 and the let's-change-the-genre of Sticker Star. Not too much, and not too little. One cool idea would be to take the Luigi's psyche thing really seriously, to the point where the final boss is a manifestation of Luigi's inferiority complex. If anyone can give character development to Mario characters, AlphaDream can.

Lastly, I'm especially happy that the art style is staying the same even with the platform shift. Too many 3DS games take the 3D so seriously that the final product ends up having some tasteless, 3D model-ridden, faux-Gamecube type style (think Fire Emblem, Mario Tennis, and the upcoming Mystery Dungeon game).

Mario Golf: World Open Grand Super Tour

We're not getting an RPG mode, are we?

New Super Luigi (Rehash) U DLC

I like the idea of 80 new levels from the better NSMB team, but price is key. 25 would probably be my limit, but they're going to squeeze 30 out of me. And inevitably, I will pay that money for this well-designed professional ROM hack and get disappointed when I remember how tired I am of this series. I would be way more excited for a 2D platformer that stars Luigi and does interesting things not seen in other Nintendo platformers.

Animal Crossing: New Leaf

Starting the summer of Nintendomination is a new entry in the immortally excellent Animal Crossing series. I can wait until June 9, but it looks like I'll have to get it at a GameStop in California thanks to E3 shenanigans happening at the exact same time. It'll be great.

HarmoKnight

It's gonna be good because Game Freak is on it. My wallet is going to be hurting when it's inevitably priced at 20 dollars, but oh well.

Dillon's Rolling Western 2 (Or Whatever)

Who cares? Maybe you do, but I sure don't.

Donkey Kong Land Returns

Since it's a port of my favorite Wii game ever, I'll buy it on cartridge for 40 dollars on day one. There probably won't be new content, but it will be a good distraction for after I get bored of Mario Golf and for before Mario & Luigi comes out in mid-September.

Sylveon

It's not part of the Nintendo Direct, but the NOA announcement about this new Eeveelution for Pokémon X and Y came moments before the Direct. All I have to say is that it's going to be a new type. That's not official news, and there is a slight chance of it being Normal, but it is probably going to be a new type. Be ready for it.

Despite my cynicism, I liked this Direct even better than the Wii U one. Mario & Luigi is going to be great (I think), DKCR 3D is going to give me the pleasure of not having to plug in my Wii sensor bar, and a New Leaf release date is making me excited for when I have to inevitably pick a Game of the Year between it and Grand Theft Auto V.

Talkback

Quote:

I can wait until June 9, but it looks like I'll have to get it at a GameStop in California thanks to E3 shenanigans happening at the exact same time.

Two words: E Shop. Oh wait... one word? eShop?

Quote:

Dillon's Rolling Western 2 (Or Whatever)
Who cares? Maybe you do, but I sure don't.

T-T This is why we can have nice things like new IPs.

FjurbanskiFebruary 15, 2013

Yeah, it was a great Nintendo Direct. Plenty of good stuff, barely any technical junk, and best of all, new games.

Mop it upFebruary 15, 2013

My reactions to Mario and Luigi, Mario Golf, and NSLU are pretty similar to this, but for everything else, I don't care about it.

LouieturkeyFebruary 15, 2013

I want new IP! Wait, that's not the new IP I wanted.  I want more Luigi!

TheFleeceFebruary 15, 2013

Yes to everything except Mario Golf, which I can always do without. I'm only down for DKLR if there's a Banana Rush Mode or something like it. There's gotta be something new with that game otherwise I can't justify its existence.

Quote from: Kairon

Quote:

I can wait until June 9, but it looks like I'll have to get it at a GameStop in California thanks to E3 shenanigans happening at the exact same time.

Two words: E Shop. Oh wait... one word? eShop?

Quote:

Dillon's Rolling Western 2 (Or Whatever)
Who cares? Maybe you do, but I sure don't.

T-T This is why we can have nice things like new IPs.

Physical or bust, Carmine  :cool;


Also, I would rather take a good sequel than a poorer new IP any day of the week.

ShyGuyFebruary 15, 2013

Respect the Dillon!

CaterkillerMatthew Osborne, Contributing WriterFebruary 16, 2013

I'd absolutely love for Sylveon to have a new type. Like "light" or something.

But judging by its name I don't know. Unless its a being of heavenly light, hmm...

AdrockFebruary 16, 2013

I'm actually trading in Paper Mario today. I couldn't get into it. The sticker element sounded interesting, but it didn't work that well in execution. Now that I can use Club Nintendo coins to get the original, there's no reason to hold onto the game since I'll be able to replay the one I really liked. That said, the new Mario and Luigi looks good. I haven't played one since the original, but unlike Sticker Star, the gameplay in Dream Team doesn't look like it strays too far from what I loved about Superstar Saga. I'm a bit disappointed that the game is not sprite-based as I really liked the art style of the series. Not a deal breaker by any means.

I'm intrigued by New Super Luigi U. That depends wholly on price.

red14February 19, 2013

When in the hell am I going to go one day without seeing somebody utterly hating on Paper Mario?

Quote from: red14

When in the hell am I going to go one day without seeing somebody utterly hating on Paper Mario?

Maybe when Sticker Star turns into a good game. ;)

Got a news tip? Send it in!
Advertisement
Advertisement