We store cookies, you can get more info from our privacy policy.
Wii

North America

Rock Band 3

by Jonathan Metts - June 16, 2010, 5:45 pm EDT
Total comments: 2

I've got a fever, and the only cure is... keyboard.

As we approached the playable Rock Band 3 demo, I knew that I had to try the keyboard controller. When a Harmonix rep asked the crowd for singers, I volunteered on the condition that I could stay on stage for the next group as well (which would include Jared and Neal from NWR). Both the audience and I had to suffer through Smash Mouth's "Walking on the Sun" (certainly not my choice), but the sacrifice gave me an opportunity to walk over to the keyboard before the next group was even on stage.

The new controller is a two-octave MIDI keyboard, with a plastic neck on the left side. The neck is apparently used in "keytar" mode, as it includes a short touch pad, but I played horizontally on a normal (if miniaturized) keyboard stand. The keys are standard width and have a nice amount of action when pressed. In mechanical terms, the controller feels just like my $200 full keyboard back home. The only difference on the keys themselves is a tiny ridge on the edge of certain buttons, ostensibly to denote the colored groupings of keys.

In normal mode, you can press any key within one of those colored groups to hit a note in the song track. There is also a way to use five adjacent white keys (middle C through G) as the five colored notes, allowing for guitar-style play. In fact, you can play guitar parts on the keyboard in this way. But for my one chance with the new controller and interface, I had to go for Pro mode.

In the keyboard's Pro mode, both white and black keys across the entire controller are used. The on-screen colors merely denote the group of keys you should use -- but the detailed note highway shows exactly which key should be pressed. As noted, I have a large keyboard at home and can play very easy scales, chords, and melodies. I can even read simple sheet music, though slowly. None of that mattered in the demo, even though the controller felt similar to my own keyboard. Pro mode destroyed me, even on the medium difficulty level.

The problem, or maybe the fun, is that pesky hand-eye link between what you see on the note highway and what your hands should do in response. The keyboard pro mode interface is so complex, especially when chords mix white and black keys, that I couldn't keep up with the pace of "Bohemian Rhapsody". It felt like playing the original Guitar Hero for the first time, and I suddenly remembered going through a process of building that mental connection, learning the basic finger positions, and developing pattern recognition. It's going to take practice, just like it did with guitar (and drums). The keyboard controller is so accurate that I'm sure piano players will learn it faster, but everyone will be challenged by the new interface, regardless of experience. This levels the playing field and presents a real change to the Rock Band gameplay, even for players who have mastered earlier games. I feel humbled by the demo, yet very eager to try again and eventually develop my keyboard skills, both in the game and on my actual instrument.

Talkback

TJ SpykeJune 16, 2010

Why did you say you had to suffer through "Walking on the Sun"? That is a good song, and better than most of the crap in the Rock Band games.

Maybe crap is a little too harsh, but "Walking on the Sun" really is a good song.

blackfootstepsJune 16, 2010

I'm suffering just thinking about it. I would have failed on purpose to cut Smash Mouth short.

Share + Bookmark





Genre Rhythm
Developer Harmonix

Worldwide Releases

na: Rock Band 3
Release Oct 26, 2010
PublisherMTV Games
RatingTeen
eu: Rock Band 3
Release Oct 29, 2010
PublisherMTV Games
Rating12+
aus: Rock Band 3
Release Oct 28, 2010
PublisherMTV Games
RatingParental Guidance
Got a news tip? Send it in!
Advertisement
Advertisement