A Link to the Past is my favorite Zelda game, but Majora's Mask would benefit more from a remake/upgraded port to 3DS. No fuzzy textures here, no sir.

If Nintendo were to ever remake A Link to the Past, I'd prefer it on Wii U with HD sprites.

Ideally I want a wholly new game, and a successor to Link to the Past would be fantastic, but any of these options would be great.

A Link to the Past (or sequel) could have some really cool effects with 3D. The multilayer dungeons with holes in the floor immediately jump to mind.


Whatever they choose, I'm definitely interested.  I was too tired of OoT to grab its 3DS remake but any of these possibilities would be day one purchases for me.

I have to agree here.  On a side note I just started Majora Mask and now I truly understand how Tingle came in to existance.

"You've met with a terrible fate, haven't you?"Yes, I have. I can't decide :(

Why not all three?

I'm pretty sure they didn't want to do 2 Zelda remakes in a row on the 3DS... and I don't want them to either... I mean Majoras mask and Link to the past were great! But I want something totally new! Maybe with Toon Link! Or, i don't know. Just a game that will completely take advantage of what the 3DS has to offer.

You guys should check out the fan made MM trailer on youtube. Here is a link : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyazYYev7Nw
Also Im a longtime reader but new member. happy to finally of joined the site

MM on 3DS pleeeeeeaaaassseeee!!!!

@Mataata

Because they have finite staff members and resources.  Magically as Nintendo may be, they are not a genie.  And if they were, that would make them a Game Genie... which as we all know, would make them property of Galoob.

A sequel to A Link to the Past would be a new game.  It's a no-brainer that I prefer that one.

Though I wonder what element of LttP Miyamoto is thinking of when he talks about returning to it.  The 2D Zeldas on the different Game Boys all have similar gameplay.  Maybe he specifically likes the parallel worlds things.

I also agree they don't want to do that.  Just from everything that they, from the way they handle their IP's to the way they dole out VC in a trickle, you sort of get the impression that Nintendo considers their existing games and IP's as some sort of limited resource.  I'd imagine they don't want to do both because they want to save either MM or LttP for the 4DS or whatever.  I also think the reason they've stopped Wii VC (and the slow rate of 3DS VC) is "banking" things for the future. 

Of course, this is why the flood of Mario platformers is befuddling, but then again, they want to make investors happy, don't they?

I always thought of FSA as a partial sucessor to LttP...

Are they talking about a remake in addition to a new game? Skyward Sword was finished over a year ago and I’m pretty sure Aonuma said they wanted make a new game before another remake. However, who knows what team is actually handling the game. If it’s a remake, it’s more likely a cooperative effort, like what they did with Grezzo for OoT. It’s strange how Miyamoto used the word “experiments”; a whole year is a long time just to be performing experiments. I don’t mean to be presumptuous, but if they wanted to get MM on 3DS, they could have already done it. I wonder what the development cycle for OoT was? Obviously Miyamoto knows more than he’s leading on, but for some reason I feel like he’s trying to throw people off the track of what’s really happening at Nintendo. From the tone of the interview it seems like they haven’t even started making whichever game it is they want to make.

I just looked it up and Aonuma sent out a Swapnote this past February saying: "Did you enjoy The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D? Thanks to everyone, the Legend of Zelda series had a very happy 25th anniversary. I hope you're looking forward to new Legend of Zelda games."
That would be a strange thing to do if they didn’t already plan of making a new title.

Can we get an official/sticky poll on this?


If they want fan input, let's give them the NWR reader stats!  ;D

I think they should make Majora's Mask 3D and also release a 3D classics version of A Link to the Past on the eShop

I'd prefer A Link to the Past, because it was my first Zelda game and I love it, but I didn't play Majora's Mask, so I wouldn't mind it either. As long as I get another portable Zelda, I'm good.

what they should have done is remaster MM for Wii U as launch game.
Use the LTTP engine and concepts to make a new game (sort of like New Super Mario Brothers takes world concepts) and that's for 3DS.

I've never played Majora and would like to, and that plus the fact that I don't like LTTP means I vote Majora.

(x) Comedy "original game" option

Honestly, I really don't care which one it ends up being. Any new Zelda is enough to get me very excited!

Adding 3D to ALttP would either destroy the game or be barely noticeable pop up sprite. The original A Link to the Past was absolutely perfect anyway, sprites and all. I rather have a new Fours Swords+1 Zelda for the WiiU with ALttP 2D sprite.

I'd love to see a WW remake on 3DS (with the missing dungeons added back in and more content+difficulty)

This is a tough decision for me. 


Honestly, I would have liked it if Nintendo would have included the M.M. remake in the remake of OoT for the 3DS.


I would have loved for the game, to be included after the final credits and give more understanding to the order of games.


However, since they didn't do it that way...I really don't want a M.M. remake...it is actually my least favorite Zelda despite having some really cool themes. 


I actually want Nintendo to take Zelda a different direction...back to its roots.  They have sorta done that with DS Zelda games but I feel the touch screen controls have been a horrible mistake. 


So I want a follow up to Link to the Past on the 3DS...one that is not a remake, but a new game in that art style and storytelling style.  That just screams beautiful classic game play...and I actually think the 3D effects could be quite breathtaking with the game. 

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I DO NOT want a MM remake!

Don't get me wrong, I love MM, but as part of the Zelda series, it's less of its own game than it is OoT 1.5. Since we already got OoT 3D (and since OoT has already been pretty much milked to death at this point anyway) it's about time one of the more sadly overlooked Zelda games finally got some new attention.

And I don't want simply a ALttP-styled  follow-up that simply reuses ALttP's sprites and 2D environment the way Four Swords Adventures did either...

The original ALttP concept deserves the full remake treatment-- a cel-shaded 3D remake of ALttP with OoT-gameplay mechanics... As long as they don't do anything stupid like use a WW-styled character design for Link. They need to stick to the art-style of the original SNES artwork, and portray Link as being in the 13-15 year old range like how Pit was portrayed in Uprising.

This SO needs to happen! Please don't let me down, Nintendo.

Why must they pursue only one option? Why not do all of them?

I do have to say, I'm rather amused by some of the same folks on here who complain about Nintendo reusing the same themes/characters/concepts also wanting more Zelda - specifically, Majora's Mask and LttP remakes. :D

Why does it amuse you that core gamers want more of a core franchise?

So everyone's happy with New Super Mario Bros. 2 and New Super Mario Bros. U?

Its better than the casual games it could have been.

And with that said, I think a lot of the griping you see over Nintendo milking too many sequels out of a franchise mainly revolves around the Mario franchise. How many Mario games have we seen the last 5 years or so? Every year we get multiple Mario games. I think that's what 90% of the griping is about. Other Nintendo franchises like Metroid, Zelda, Star Fox, etc. aren't getting these endless yearly repetitive sequels the way Mario does. That's why talk about a new Zelda still holds a lot of excitement, whereas talk of another Mario game isn't quite as exciting because there's just so many of them.

*actual* Mario games, still, aren't that common.  Sure, we get Mario-skinned games like Mario Tennis and Mario Party, but an actual Mario platformer (2D or 3D) isn't something we tend to get more than once a year.

Hell, it took nearly 20 years to get an original, new Mario 2D Platformer...  And now, because we're getting a few more (mind you, a new game for new systems... not even a same-system "upgrade"), well... Mario's played out.

13 years, not 20 (1992 to 2005). NSMBU looks like a really great game, I plan to get it (not sure on NSMB2 yet).