That's what happens when you listen to hardcore gamers...

100k is really low.
I also wonder how many copies were pirated.
I'm considering getting RGC.

I thought King's Story wasn't coming until the Fall?

Nope late July. It's sad that Retro Game Challenge flopped since it's a fantastic game.

Hardcore gamers? XSEED mainly publishes games that are niche and people want to play but the big companies don't want to see brought over.

I doubt there was a HUGE hardcore following for Retro Game Challenge when it was published. Fans saw the game, it looked cool and XSEED tried to bring it over.

XSEED is just trying to bring more games over. Isn't this a GOOD thing?

Not if they lose money doing it. Though I wonder where it's sales are now. 100k is a pretty low number. I also know I plan on getting it before Summer is over.

Once again, the videogame industry's reluctance to tell us what is considered profitable makes it hard to determine whether XSEED is being profitable or not. Obviously purchasing the rights to the license and the translation work take some money. But it seems they are doing well enough  that they are publishing titles on many consoles, mainly the Wii. So it seems they are making profit, but need the sales numbers to convince publishers that the IP is worth bringing over.

You guys also have to realize that Xseed is a very small company (about 12 people that's run by the former president of Square-Enix USA), and they survive on localizing left over scraps from other publishers that don't want to localize specific games  to America. Xseed also gets some games from their parent company, AQ Interactive. To decide whether they can localize the game, first they see if it's feasible to get the publishing rights then the company playtests the game to determine whether it's fun and worth their time to bring it over. They struck a deal with Marvelous for localization and co-publishing a set of games, part of the deal was to help Marvelous gain a US presence.

Namco Bandai rarely allows another company to get publishing rights to their games so that's why it's a shame that Retro Game Challenge sold poorly. The only reason why they get rights to some Namco games like Fragile and Retro Game Challenge is because the President of Xseed knows people in Namco Bandai, so we should be grateful that we are getting it. Europe/Australia is getting Fragile in 2010 courtesy of Rising Star. The only other company that gets publishing rights of Namco Bandai games is Atlus but they usually only go for Banpresto and Flight Plan games(both are owned by Namco Bandai).

I didn't realize how much of this localization process was a big political game. Crazy. Makes me appreciate even more that games like RGC and Fragile are coming/have come here.

Yeah it's a crazy process, part of the reason why I appreciate companies like Xseed, Aksys, Atlus and NIS America. It's easier to get rights from smaller companies likes Success or Sting, but it's hard to get it from bigger companies. Part of me wishes that Atlus pursues Disaster Day of Crisis or Fatal Frame 4 since Atlus did publish Cubivore (GameCube) in America, which was a game that Nintendo published in Japan. They also recently got the rights from Sega to publish Shiren the Wanderer 3 Mystery Dungeon for Wii (YES YES YES!!) and rights from Sony of Japan/From Software to publish Demon's Souls (Epic win!) for the PS3 in America.

Maybe Atlus has tried to get D:DOC or FF4. Nintendo is very tough on this, they refused to let Atlus localize Mother 3.

I believe XSeed said once they were interested in publishing Fatal Frame and would do it if they could so maybe something cam be reached there. Though I don't see why they can't just fix the game themselves.

Nintendo of America called, they want their "we hate earthbound" pins.

IIRC Tecmo has a deal with Nintendo that only Nintendo is allowed to publish FF4 but they're refusing because Tecmo are being dicks over the flaws in the game. Without the deal Tecmo would publish the game itself.

If we're going to talk about games published by Nintendo that need to come to the west, Chou Soujuu Mecha MG!

Is that that mech assault game they released in Japane a little bit ago?

Yeah though it was quite a while ago.

RGC is a fantastic game, everyone should get it. as for the localization... get rid of the 'plot' if that helps! just give me challenge and then the game. make me figure the rest out (or learn to read japanese) =D

I'd get it if it was released in Europe.

They could sell the Japanese version here with a copy of My Japanese Coach. ;)

I wonder if they would consider releasing RGC 2 on the DSiWare service? That would at least save on the distribution and material costs. Translate and put it on the service. Much cheaper. Though the question of how many you could sell on the service is questionable.

DSiWare puts a price cap on it, a retail game costs more. Someone suggested selling the individual games on DSiWare but I'm not sure that'd work if RGC has some sort of metagame going on.

There's always WiiWare. The game doesn't use any of the DS' touch or other exotic features, right?