Even if I waited years, and in the preceeding weeks to E3 I was unable to sleep, only to be revealed a short clip.. Zelda Wii U is still my pick. It's a bit of fan boy I understand, but even if Aonuma had just givin me a title and a rendering of the logo I would probably have been happy just the same. With its long time in preproduction, receiving a video was expected by me, but I think back to Skyward Sword and its past teaser and all we received was an image of Fi and Link... nothing more... so I am thankful for what we all got and made it easier to be even more excited about it.
Captain Toad would be next on my list though. When they mentioned its title, at first I was put off by a game based solely around Toad and his inabilities, but after the Treehouse exclusive I can't wait to buy it as well.