Messages

[wulffman04]

1

TalkBack / RE:REVIEWS: Super Mario Galaxy

« on: November 13, 2007, 11:32:10 AM »

Quote
Originally posted by: wulffman04

Quote
Originally posted by: comfortboy

Quote
Originally posted by: planetidiot
Good game, but 10?  I'm sorry, if there's anything at all wrong with the game, it shouldn't be a ten.  And there are some things wrong with the game.

Karl and Evan Talked about this on Radio Free Nintendo. I completely disagree with your logic. A 10 shouldn't get a -.5 every time a reviewer finds something that irks them. Like they said in a perfect reviewers world there would be no out of 10 score. But until these meta-review dependent people start reading the reviews and understanding why a game that had something that slightly detracted from the experience could still get a 10.

Yeah, you don't deserve an opinion! We're going to have Karl and Evan argue this point until your ears bleed!

fair enough-walks away-

[planetidiot]

2

TalkBack / RE:REVIEWS: Super Mario Galaxy

« on: November 13, 2007, 07:22:30 AM »

Quote
Originally posted by: planetidiot
Good game, but 10?  I'm sorry, if there's anything at all wrong with the game, it shouldn't be a ten.  And there are some things wrong with the game.

Karl and Evan Talked about this on Radio Free Nintendo. I completely disagree with your logic. A 10 shouldn't get a -.5 every time a reviewer finds something that irks them. Like they said in a perfect reviewers world there would be no out of 10 score. But until these meta-review dependent people start reading the reviews and understanding why a game that had something that slightly detracted from the experience could still get a 10.

3

TalkBack / RE:THQ Easing Away From Multiplatform Releases

« on: April 18, 2007, 05:50:16 AM »

Well I give them credit for Pilot Wings 64 created by Paradigm Entertainment, which is part of THQ now but I dont see them putting out a worthwhile pilotwings game on the wii although the concept with the remote and nunchuck makes my mouth water.