9
« on: July 23, 2006, 12:53:15 PM »
As much as the Wiimote opens up new game play possibilities in other type of games, I just don't see it as being a great instrutment for traditional sports game, with the exception of football, tennis, baseball, and golf. I'm not 100% confident that the Wiimote will translate well to basketball. Also, in baseball, the controller is obviously intuitive with swinging the bat, but what about pitching and fielding? I just can't seem to imagine how the controller will be use for that purpose. In basketball, I can see the controller excel at defense, but on the offensive side of the ball, I don't see it provide the magic that you would expect. As for soccer, I don't see the controllers being used beyond shooting the ball. In my opinion, I don't see a lot of sports games on the Wii that will be good. It will be more of a hit or a miss if developers use the Wiimote. In certain type of sports game, the experience will be revolutionary, in other games, it will be more of a sparkling innovation. With this in mind, I think Nintendo should definitely include the traditional controller as part of its package. Without it, we will be missing out on some potential hits that are just more suitable to the traditional controllers. In the end, I think the Wii will have a crap load of sports title that would heavily benefit from the use of the Wiimote, and that would be football, baseball, tennis, and golf. I don't think basketball and soccer will be abundant. Basketball will probably get better later in the Wii's life, but I expect early titles to be sparkling innovationy and probably a bit frustrating.
If Madden fails to get traction, I don't think the Wii will have a drought of sports title as other publishers will come up with their own unique approach. I think in the beginning, I would think that a lot of sports title will either fail to impress because of ackward usage of the controller. The games will be better with each iteration as developers learn what works and what doesn't through trial and error. I think sports title on the Wii will get very good in the second half of the Wii's life.