We store cookies, you can get more info from our privacy policy.
Wii

My Thoughts on Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility

by Lauren Ronaghan - May 5, 2009, 10:32 pm EDT
Total comments: 26

The game begins with my character, which I named after myself, on a ship en route to Waffle Island. The ship's captain, Pascal, asks me questions about myself such as my name and birthday in a manner similar to Nintendo's Animal Crossing series. However, the turbulent seas cause me to fall and bump my head, rendering me unconscious until I awake, safely on Waffle Island and in the care of the proprietors of Sundae Inn.

After fully recovering from my accident, Hamilton, the Mayor of Waffle Island, asks me if I would prefer a Town Plot, Mountain Plot, or Seaside Plot, and upon my decision, takes me to my new ranch. Each plot has its benefits and drawbacks. The Town Plot, which is close to Waffle Town's shops and inhabitants, has the smallest amount of land, which limits the amount of crops one can farm. The Mountain Plot is the furthest away, but has the most land. The Seaside Plot has a medium-sized land parcel, but is on the beach, making it ideal for those who like to fish. I selected the Mountain Plot, which worked great for me once Luke, the carpenter's son, chopped the Harvest Tree that was blocking the path from my house to the Ganache Mine District. This was ideal since I had chosen Owen, who spends his days in Ganache Mine, to be my one true love.

The game is difficult in the beginning, as the character isn't used to the hard work of ranch life and runs out of energy really fast from mundane tasks like pulling weeds and digging holes, let alone sowing seeds and watering plants. Money is also hard to come by in the beginning, and I would often spend an entire day in Ganache Mine just to be able to afford a Buckwheat Cocktail to woo my beloved Owen. As with other Harvest Moon games, the player gives gifts to other characters, and in return the character begins to like them, measured by hearts. Heart levels make certain events possible, such as going on a date with an eligible bachelor or bachelorette, and even later marrying them. It's also necessary to raise heart levels of Rival Couples, who will also marry.

Harvest Moon is all about smart investing, and investments take money as well as time. For instance, saving up to buy a Calf takes quite a bit of time, as does allowing it to grow for a season (28 days) until it is an adult and can produce Milk. However, Milk is an excellent product, which brings in the Gold as well as raises the level of Brownie Ranch, making more animals available for purchase. Players can also turn Milk into either Cheese or Butter; Wool, Flax, and Silk into Yarn and Thread; and Eggs into Mayonnaise, Duckonnaise, and Ostonnaise. Insider's tip: Silkworms are well worth their high price, as silk thread has an absurdly high shipping value.

However, there's more to the game besides making money and buying presents. There's also a story to the island! Before your move to the island, the Harvest Goddess Tree fell, causing great distress. This broke the Rainbows that kept the seas calm, which explains your rough voyage on the high seas. As your character settles in, he or she is expected to work towards restoring these Rainbows by speaking with the Harvest Sprites who guard them and concoting Rainbow Recipes which bring the Rainbows back! Each Rainbow serves as a Bridge to a new part of the Island that was previously unable to be reached. The first Rainbow calms the seas, which sends Pascal out to sea again, returning twice a month with new residents. The best part about this is that it furthers an actual story, convincing you to keep playing the game, to make the next Rainbow so you can walk across it to Toucan Island and Mount Gelato.

Despite these interesting, fun, and sometimes plain cute aspects of the game, there are a few flaws which need to be addressed. The most obvious are the load times, which are sometimes painstakingly slow. I really don't know why it would take so unbearably long to enter my chicken coop, but it does. The loading isn’t bad enough to turn me off to the game, but for someone who isn't instantly hooked by the cute graphics and story it might be impossible to forgive. Another issue that I've encountered is the game's inability to recognize which direction the player is facing. Often times I find myself standing directly in front of an egg pressing A to pick it up, only to wind up picking up the chicken who is 45 degrees to my left. Frustruating, but definitely not deal-breaking.

One thing that I cannot deny is how absolutely lost I would be if I had not bought the Player's Guide, which let me know which Cocktails Owen loves best, in what Season I can grow a Good Tomato for Ben's Rainbow, or if it's more profitible to ship an Egg or fry it first (fry it only if it's not Perfect of Shining). All in all, the Player's Guide is as crucial as the game is a blast.

I might be new to the series, but Tree of Tranquility has definitely hooked me. While games like Rune Factory: Frontier and Animal Crossing: City Folk might be more polished, I'm not interested in the combat of Rune Factory or the real-time mechanic used in Animal Crossing. Harvest Moon is a game I can take at my own pace, and quickly get back into after putting it down for a little while.

Talkback

StratosMay 06, 2009

Interesting thoughts. I've been debating which Harvest Moon/Rune Factory game I should get for my sister since she likes the series a lot and this really helps with my decision.

EasyCureMay 06, 2009

Quote from: Stratos

Interesting thoughts. I've been debating which Harvest Moon/Rune Factory game I should get for my sister since she likes the series a lot and this really helps with my decision.

I'd love to try out Rune Factory for Wii but it would actually be my first time playing a game in the series. I never heard about the series until the Wii game was announced (thanks for the thread Bill!), and only then did I learn that RF is a HM spin-off, and i've loved the HM since the original SNES game.

Is RF2 out for DS? Because that might be a better investment (timewise) than a console version of RF.. oh but i'm getting off topic.

Back to Harvest Moon. These impressions make me want to pick up the game, but at the same time things like the slow loading.. i just know thats something that would kill the experience for me. I'm glad the art style goes back to the cutsey look of the original titles, because the first Harvest Moon on Gamecube left a sour taste in my mouth. Still though, considering how many Harvest Moon titles have been released, you'd think one of them would finally fix the little issues they ALL seem to have (like sloppy controls/detection).

Oh well, I have the SNES version on the Wii's Virtual Console, and i'm holding out for the N64 as well because I enjoyed that one a ton more over the original (it included more of the story aspects, and you didn't have the two year time limit).

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: Stratos

Interesting thoughts. I've been debating which Harvest Moon/Rune Factory game I should get for my sister since she likes the series a lot and this really helps with my decision.

Glad to know that I could help! Any more Qs, feel free to ask :)

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: EasyCure

Quote from: Stratos

Interesting thoughts. I've been debating which Harvest Moon/Rune Factory game I should get for my sister since she likes the series a lot and this really helps with my decision.

I'd love to try out Rune Factory for Wii but it would actually be my first time playing a game in the series. I never heard about the series until the Wii game was announced (thanks for the thread Bill!), and only then did I learn that RF is a HM spin-off, and i've loved the HM since the original SNES game.

Is RF2 out for DS? Because that might be a better investment (timewise) than a console version of RF.. oh but i'm getting off topic.

Back to Harvest Moon. These impressions make me want to pick up the game, but at the same time things like the slow loading.. i just know thats something that would kill the experience for me. I'm glad the art style goes back to the cutsey look of the original titles, because the first Harvest Moon on Gamecube left a sour taste in my mouth. Still though, considering how many Harvest Moon titles have been released, you'd think one of them would finally fix the little issues they ALL seem to have (like sloppy controls/detection).

Oh well, I have the SNES version on the Wii's Virtual Console, and i'm holding out for the N64 as well because I enjoyed that one a ton more over the original (it included more of the story aspects, and you didn't have the two year time limit).

I've actually never played any RF games, and this is my first HM game  :-[ so I unfortunately can't help out with anything RF related (yet!).

The slow loading is something that definitely has potential to ruin the game for people who just aren't *that* into the game, but if you do get into it they are definitely bearable.  Plus, it's a nice time to eat some popcorn if you have any on hand.

I have heard that the 64 release is the best one out there, and I do look forward to playing it soon via VC.  Just right now, I'm so wrapped up in HM: ToT that I really don't want to get into too much else.

I wasn't even aware of a 2 year limit in the SNES release!  There's not one in ToT, in fact, in this game you can choose to play as your child once he/she grows up.  There's a lot (a LOT) of playability in this game, which is great; a 2 year time limit sounds so unfortunate.

And one more thing: I felt the need to point out the sloppy detection, because it is pretty annoying, but I am pretttty sure the only place I've experienced it (at least chronically) was inside my Coop.

GoldenPhoenixMay 06, 2009

Robots always have the best blog posts!

Quote from: GoldenPhoenix

Robots always have the best blog posts!

Especially robots who reply later and have a picture of a cat with a mustache.

StratosMay 06, 2009

It's actually a 2 1/2 year limit in the original. I think it was a nice thing because it gave you an end goal. Though I don't see any harm in letting the game continue on afterward.

Yeah, like what Easycure said, the 1st GC version left a sour taste in my mouth and killed the series to me until I saw Rune Factory. The N64 one is the best I agree and then the SNES one is close behind it. The only fault I have for the SNES one is that there are few things to do in the fall and winter aside from crops and wooing. I was too good when I played it again on the VC and so I had nothing to do half the day. It got too monotonous because I already had all the house upgrades by the first Summer and was stalling with marriage because I wanted to get married in the Winter since that's my favorite season in real life. I just kept buying cows and chickens. It's now the same old chores. The N64 one almost has too much side things to do. I really liked mining.

The N64 game was great but I'd have to say that Friends of Mineral Town on the GBA is the best game in the series. I bought Rune Factory Frontier for the Wii but haven't played it yet, this post is making me want to.

EasyCureMay 06, 2009

First of all that avatar is awesome (and who the hell is mamacitalew!? nice to meet ya though!), secondly those impressions were really good, and i'm glad you mentioned the detection issue because its actually been a staple in HM games ;) lol You have no idea how many eggs i've dropped in the original game because of that,yeesh! Since i probably won't be picking up HM:ToT, i most likely will continue playing the original on the virtual console.I stopped in winter because, like Stratos i had nothing to do.

Quote from: insanolord

The N64 game was great but I'd have to say that Friends of Mineral Town on the GBA is the best game in the series. I bought Rune Factory Frontier for the Wii but haven't played it yet, this post is making me want to.

I'll be honest, i never played it because i didn't get a GBA until late in its lifespan, and even now i only have about 5 games for it. I guess i should track a copy down since even after 1 or 2 (or 3??) Harvest Moon releases on the DS, people are still saying that FoMT is the better (portable) HM game.

I-Lo, when you play RFF you should lemme know what you think about it, since its still on my list of "maybe" games.

Yes, I called you I-Lo. Deal with it.

Friends of Mineral Town improves on a lot of the things from the N64 game. The mining is a bigger part of the game and you use the ore you mine to upgrade your tools. You can build a kitchen for your house in HM64 but in FoMT you can actually use it to cook things.

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: GoldenPhoenix

Robots always have the best blog posts!

It's because we're perfect machines  ;)

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: Stratos

It's actually a 2 1/2 year limit in the original. I think it was a nice thing because it gave you an end goal. Though I don't see any harm in letting the game continue on afterward.

Yeah, like what Easycure said, the 1st GC version left a sour taste in my mouth and killed the series to me until I saw Rune Factory. The N64 one is the best I agree and then the SNES one is close behind it. The only fault I have for the SNES one is that there are few things to do in the fall and winter aside from crops and wooing. I was too good when I played it again on the VC and so I had nothing to do half the day. It got too monotonous because I already had all the house upgrades by the first Summer and was stalling with marriage because I wanted to get married in the Winter since that's my favorite season in real life. I just kept buying cows and chickens. It's now the same old chores. The N64 one almost has too much side things to do. I really liked mining.

Winter's always difficult but ToT does make it necessary because certain crops for the Rainbows can only be grown in the winter. 
As far as "the same old chores" I find I spend hours every morning milking cows and making cheese, collecting eggs and making mayonaise, collecting silk and making thread, etc.  By the time I'm done I don't have much time -- having a horse makes it so much easier to get around quickly.
There's two mines in ToT.  Ganache Mine is available at the very start of the game and is fairly deep, I think thirty floors.  The other mine on Mt. Gelato is difficult to get to, having to complete three rainbows and feeding a bear a copious amount of honey.  Honestly, I haven't gotten there yet.  I don't see how it'll work because it takes so long to get to that if I do my morning chores, will I even have time to explore it's 50 floors?

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: insanolord

The N64 game was great but I'd have to say that Friends of Mineral Town on the GBA is the best game in the series. I bought Rune Factory Frontier for the Wii but haven't played it yet, this post is making me want to.

I keep hearing about the 64 game!  I'll definitely get it on VC once I "finish" ToT.

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: EasyCure

First of all that avatar is awesome (and who the hell is mamacitalew!? nice to meet ya though!), secondly those impressions were really good, and i'm glad you mentioned the detection issue because its actually been a staple in HM games ;) lol You have no idea how many eggs i've dropped in the original game because of that,yeesh! Since i probably won't be picking up HM:ToT, i most likely will continue playing the original on the virtual console.I stopped in winter because, like Stratos i had nothing to do.

Quote from: insanolord

The N64 game was great but I'd have to say that Friends of Mineral Town on the GBA is the best game in the series. I bought Rune Factory Frontier for the Wii but haven't played it yet, this post is making me want to.

I'll be honest, i never played it because i didn't get a GBA until late in its lifespan, and even now i only have about 5 games for it. I guess i should track a copy down since even after 1 or 2 (or 3??) Harvest Moon releases on the DS, people are still saying that FoMT is the better (portable) HM game.

I-Lo, when you play RFF you should lemme know what you think about it, since its still on my list of "maybe" games.

Yes, I called you I-Lo. Deal with it.

Haha thank you, thank you.  I've been around NWR for about a year now but don't post very much, unfortunately.  I did have a few comments on De Blob way back when. And nice to meet you, too!

The detection in ToT just cause me to pick up chickens instead of eggs, even when the eggs are directly in front of me  >:( Haven't dropped any though!

As for as DS HM games, I have Island of Happyness which I bought after ToT, and I hardly play it.  My friend has HM Cute, which she hardly plays after picking up ToT.  Maybe we just like consoles better?  I know I do.

I would definitely like to hear about RFF, even though I'm more into the petting the cow and not battling foes.  What can I say, lover not fighter... most of the time.

mamacitalewLauren Ronaghan, Staff AlumnusMay 06, 2009

Quote from: insanolord

Friends of Mineral Town improves on a lot of the things from the N64 game. The mining is a bigger part of the game and you use the ore you mine to upgrade your tools. You can build a kitchen for your house in HM64 but in FoMT you can actually use it to cook things.

You can do both in ToT!  A number of appliances are usless (I think there's a woodburning stove) but the frying pan, mixer, oven, etc. are nice to have, and may even be essential for some Rainbow recipes (a lot of Rainbow recipe items are available for sale at Flea Markets).  (PS Decent Eggs are worth more fried, but Perfect and Shining Eggs are not.)  I also don't know how the houses work in the other games, but you can continue upgrading your ToT house to a level four or five (sorry not sure!!).  I'm currently at a level four, giving me more counter space (I couldn't fit all of my appliances out at once in a level three) and an upstairs where I put my couches that I can't sit on, my TV for when I feel like learning about the animals of the island or the weather (a bit useless as the weather is on the HUD) and my telephone, which I rarely use since I have the strategy guide which tells me business hours.

NintendadMay 06, 2009

I really enjoyed Tree of Tranquility. I put over 90 hours into that game. Reading the impressions brought back some memories because it's been a few months since I played it. However, I would really try to play the game without a strategy guide in hand if possible. It's much more fun discovering a new mine on your own.

As for Rune Factory Frontier, that's what I'm playing right now, around 65 hours into it. I love it but because of the dungeon fighting, my wife won't touch it. She played ToT more than I did. Anybody looking to get started with Frontier, take my advice and read up about the Runey's when you first start playing. The manual explains little about them, the game doesn't tell you much, and yet the management of them are vital if you want your crops to keep growing. You can really make things tough if you ignore them.

I've played most of the Harvest Moon games and like most, the first one on the GCN was my least favorite, A Wonderful Life I think it was. But the second one on the GCN, Magical Melody was very fun and compares to ToT.  I also thought Friends of a Mineral Town on GBA was good. Out of the 2 Rune Factories on the DS, I loved the first one but could never get into the second one for whatever reason.

EasyCureMay 07, 2009

Man, good good stuff. I wanna play a HM game now, if only i had the time!

Flames_of_chaosLukasz Balicki, Staff AlumnusMay 07, 2009

I liked the SNES and N64 harvest moon games but after that it's all Rune Factory. I think the original Harvest Moon team pretty much develops the Rune Factory games now which is fine by me. The Wii Rune Factory game is crack.

EasyCureMay 07, 2009

Quote from: Flames_of_chaos

I liked the SNES and N64 harvest moon games but after that it's all Rune Factory. I think the original Harvest Moon team pretty much develops the Rune Factory games now which is fine by me. The Wii Rune Factory game is crack.

Crack is good? All my life i was taught to believe its whack.

RABicleMay 08, 2009

I disagree with this whole "N64 is da best" one. Sure it was great but Back To Nature on PSX was a step up from that and then Friends of Mineral TOwn WAS back to nature but ever bigger somehow.

EasyCureMay 08, 2009

Quote from: RABicle

I disagree with this whole "N64 is da best" one. Sure it was great but Back To Nature on PSX was a step up from that and then Friends of Mineral TOwn WAS back to nature but ever bigger somehow.

LOL.. Harvest Moon on 'hardcore' consoles...

Mop it upMay 08, 2009

I like Harvest Moon 64, but with the mixed opinions people have on every other release I've been hesitant to try any others. It's so confusing to figure out which one would be a good one to get. This Wii version sounds interesting though, I might check it out. I want to play Harvest Moon, but not the N64 one yet again.

spitmanMay 20, 2009

The camera killed it for me. I played it for a few days and sold it.  The camera angle is annoying, it's pointing down and you can't really look where you are going unless you stop and move it up to look around.  Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life on the Gamecube was so much better, it was full 3D, not 2.5D or whatever this is.  Even Harvest Moon: Magical Melody on Gamecube was excellent, it wasn't full 3D but the camera angle was so much better. 

I know the Wii isn't the fastest system out there but some titles on the Wii are a step down from their previous Gamecube titles... I don't get it....  do the programmers just not try anymore?

Working on the Rune Factory Frontier review, let me say this:

There is a TON of things to do.  It's almost absurd how much stuff there is to do in this game.  It takes a long time to move through the day because I want to do it all.  I spend a long time waiting to recharge at the bath house (it opens at 3 PM).

After probably twenty hours I'm just now entering the third season in the game.  That's about twenty minutes of gameplay a day. 

It is a very polished game.  I've played the SNES, N64, and GC Harvest Moon games, and this game is more polished than any of them.

Other question somebody asked, Rune Factory 2 DS is out.

NinGurl69 *hugglesMay 25, 2009

I just started diving into Girl Factory Frontier today.  Start is slow, waiting for key events/days to pass by, but it's got this endearing old-school factor to it, love it.  Sounds like there's tons more things to do once they open up.

Oh my, how they blush.

Quote from: NinGurl69

I just started diving into Girl Factory Frontier today. 

12:3 Woman to Man ratio

12:1 Woman to sane man ratio.

It's like the NWR Forums, but reversed.

And it's 12:0

Got a news tip? Send it in!
Advertisement
Advertisement