Animal Crossing.
Good call - but am actively playing New Leaf with my kids, so probably won't go back to revisit the Wii version. (Just the thought of all those weeds, so many years later... *shudder*)
... Might I also suggest Silent Hill: Shattered Memories?
Ooh... Good suggestion! Snowy, suspenseful, and supposed to be an excellent game by all accounts. The only reason I might hold back is that I want a few good games held back instead of playing all the best games and leaving the "not so exciting" titles afterwards.
... Aragorn's Quest ... Epic Mickey ... Secret Files: Tunguska ... NiGHTS Journey of Dreams ...
I own the first two, and both are interesting suggestions. Aragorn's Quest seemed to get middling reviews, but looks nice and Lord of the Rings has kind of a Christmas appeal (when else will I ever have enough free time to watch those epics movies). Epic Mickey is also just a gorgeous idea, even though all reports suggest the gameplay doesn't live up to the concept.
Tunguska is one I missed out on, but since the sequel never got released in North America don't feel too bad about it.
NiGHTS is a previously-owned game that got sold. It was something I tried to enjoy, but just couldn't.
... For snowy stuff, yeah just pick Cursed Mountain and go with it. ...
Yeah - I think this will be the pick. Although I did just start
Batman: The Brave and the Bold - The Video Game so will probably polish that off first to make a dent in the backlog. It's supposed to be pretty quick.
Thanks everyone!